CVE-2023-50868
A public proof of concept exists; no exploitation attested.
- Published2024-02-14
- Fixed in9.19.21 · 9.18.24 · 9.16.48
- WeaknessCWE-400
Am I affected?
Debian, Ubuntu or Red Hat sometimes backport a fix without changing the upstream version number: such a version reads « to verify », never « affected ».With a domain, we read the version its public headers and pages expose. A distribution build can carry the fix under an older number.
Description
The Closest Encloser Proof aspect of the DNS protocol (in RFC 5155 when RFC 9276 guidance is skipped) allows remote attackers to cause a denial of service (CPU consumption for SHA-1 computations) via DNSSEC responses in a random subdomain attack, aka the "NSEC3" issue. The RFC 5155 specification implies that an algorithm must perform thousands of iterations of a hash function in certain situations.
Timeline
dates in UTC- 2024-02-1416:15CVE publishedNVD
Versions per branch
NVD| Branch | Affected | Fixed in | Source |
|---|---|---|---|
| 9.19 | ≥ 9.19.0, < 9.19.21 | 9.19.21 | NVD |
| 9.18 | ≥ 9.18.0, < 9.18.24 | 9.18.24 | NVD |
| 9.18 | ≥ 9.18.11, < 9.18.24 | 9.18.24 | NVD |
| 9.x | ≥ 9.0.0, < 9.16.48 | 9.16.48 | NVD |
| 9.x | ≥ 9.9.3, < 9.16.48 | 9.16.48 | NVD |
| Branch | Affected | Fixed in | Source |
|---|---|---|---|
| 6.0 | = 6.0 | no fix published | NVD |
| 7.0 | = 7.0 | no fix published | NVD |
| 8.0 | = 8.0 | no fix published | NVD |
| 8.2 | = 8.2 | no fix published | NVD |
| 8.4 | = 8.4 | no fix published | NVD |
| Branch | Affected | Fixed in | Source |
|---|---|---|---|
| 5.0 | ≥ 5.0.0, < 5.0.2 | 5.0.2 | NVD |
| 4.9 | ≥ 4.9.0, < 4.9.3 | 4.9.3 | NVD |
| 4.8 | < 4.8.5 | 4.8.5 | NVD |
5 more products in the sources.
as publishedRanges as NVD and OSV publish them; a distribution’s build can be fixed under an older number.
Distribution builds and vendor advisories
Packages from OSV.dev and products from the vendors' CSAF advisories.
version not verifiedVersions not verified: read as OSV.dev and the vendors publish them, not checked against each vendor's release list.
Packages
- bindWolfiall versions · fixed in 9.18.24-r0
- bindTuxCare:OracleLinux:6all versions · fixed in 33:9.8.2-0.68.rc1.el6.11.tuxcare.els8and 5 other packages
- bindTuxCare:CentOS:8.5all versions · fixed in 32:9.11.26-6.el8.tuxcare.els6and 16 other packages
- bindTuxCare:CentOS:8.4all versions · fixed in 32:9.11.26-4.el8.4.tuxcare.els7and 16 other packages
- bindTuxCare:CentOS:7all versions · fixed in 32:9.11.4-26.P2.el7.14.tuxcare.els2and 15 other packages
- bindTuxCare:CentOS:7all versions · fixed in 33:9.11.4-26.P2.el7_9.15.tuxcare.els1and 15 other packages
- bindTuxCare:CentOS:6all versions · fixed in 33:9.8.2-0.68.rc1.el6.11.tuxcare.els8and 5 other packages
- bindTuxCare:AlmaLinux:9.2all versions · fixed in 32:9.16.23-11.el9_2.2.tuxcare.els1and 9 other packages
235 more package ranges on OSV.dev
Vendor advisories
bind9: Preparing an NSEC3 closest encloser proof can exhaust CPU resources
Red Hat Security Advisory: bind and bind-dyndb-ldap security update
Red Hat Security Advisory: unbound security update
Siemens SINEC INS
SINEC INS
SSA-915275: Multiple Vulnerabilities in SINEC INS Before V1.0 SP2 Update 3
SINEC INS
Red Hat Security Advisory: dnsmasq security update
29 more advisories
Fix
- Update Isc bind to 9.19.21 · 9.18.24 · 9.16.48
- Vendor fix Red Hat Product Security RHSA-2025:0039 · 36 productsFor details on how to apply this update, which includes the changes described in this advisory, refer to: https://access.redhat.com/articles/11258
- Vendor fix Siemens ProductCERT SSA-915275 · 1 productUpdate to V1.0 SP2 Update 3 or later version
- Vendor fix CISA ICSA-24-319-08 · 1 productUpdate to V1.0 SP2 Update 3 or later version
- Vendor fix Red Hat Product Security RHSA-2024:3741 · 264 productsFor details on how to apply this update, which includes the changes described in this advisory, refer to: https://access.redhat.com/articles/11258 After installing the update, the BIND daemon (named) will be restarted automatically.
- Vendor fix Red Hat Product Security RHSA-2024:2720 · 220 productsBefore applying this update, make sure all previously released errata relevant to your system have been applied. For details on how to apply this update, refer to: https://access.redhat.com/articles/11258
- Vendor fix Red Hat Product Security RHSA-2024:2551 · 89 productsBefore applying this update, make sure all previously released errata relevant to your system have been applied. For details on how to apply this update, refer to: https://access.redhat.com/articles/11258
Advisories and patches
- access.redhat.comVendor Advisory
- docs.powerdns.comVendor Advisory
- gitlab.nic.czRelease Notes
- lists.debian.orgVendor Advisory
- lists.debian.orgVendor Advisory
- lists.fedoraproject.orgVendor Advisory
Detection
read 2026-11-01 01:02 UTC- Nuclei template
- none so far ProjectDiscovery
- Exploit-DB
- no entry Exploit-DB
- Proof of concept
- PoC-in-GitHub1 repository, unverifiedknown since 2026-11-01Goethe-Universitat-Cybersecurity/NSEC3-Encloser-Attack
- Metasploit modules
- none listed Metasploit Framework
Sources
- CISA-ADPSSVC decisionnone2024-02-19
- CISA-ADPCVSS 3.17.52025-05-12
- NVDCVSS 3.17.5read 2026-10-23
- CISA-ADPweakness (CWE)CWE-4002025-05-12
- FIRST EPSSEPSS score74.3 %read 2026-11-18
- PoC-in-GitHubproof of concept1known since 2026-11-01
- OSVaffected packages—
- GitHub Advisoriesadvisory—
Identifiers
- AZL-34441same flawAzure Linux · MIT
- AZL-35329same flawAzure Linux · MIT
- CGA-28p4-5w5g-rhpmsame flawChainguard · CC-BY-NC-ND-4.0
- CGA-hr68-rc2v-xc26same flawChainguard · CC-BY-NC-ND-4.0
- EUVD-2023-55601same flawENISA EUVD · LicenseRef-ENISA-legal-notice
- GHSA-pv4h-p8jr-6cv2same flawGitHub Advisory Database · CC-BY-4.0
- ALSA-2024:0965advisory covering several CVEsAlmaLinux · MIT
- ALSA-2024:0977advisory covering several CVEsAlmaLinux · MIT
- ALSA-2024:1334advisory covering several CVEsAlmaLinux · MIT
- ALSA-2024:1335advisory covering several CVEsAlmaLinux · MIT
- ALSA-2024:1781advisory covering several CVEsAlmaLinux · MIT
- ALSA-2024:1782advisory covering several CVEsAlmaLinux · MIT
- ALSA-2024:1789advisory covering several CVEsAlmaLinux · MIT
- ALSA-2024:2551advisory covering several CVEsAlmaLinux · MIT
- ALSA-2024:3271advisory covering several CVEsAlmaLinux · MIT
- DLA-3736-1advisory covering several CVEsDebian · LicenseRef-unstated
- DLA-3816-1advisory covering several CVEsDebian · LicenseRef-unstated
- DLA-3859-1advisory covering several CVEsDebian · LicenseRef-unstated
- DLA-3974-1advisory covering several CVEsDebian · LicenseRef-unstated
- DSA-5620-1advisory covering several CVEsDebian · LicenseRef-unstated
- DSA-5621-1advisory covering several CVEsDebian · LicenseRef-unstated
- DSA-5626-1advisory covering several CVEsDebian · LicenseRef-unstated
- DSA-5633-1advisory covering several CVEsDebian · LicenseRef-unstated
- MGASA-2024-0038advisory covering several CVEsMageia · LicenseRef-unstated
- MGASA-2024-0039advisory covering several CVEsMageia · LicenseRef-unstated
- MGASA-2024-0041advisory covering several CVEsMageia · LicenseRef-unstated
- OESA-2024-1210advisory covering several CVEsopenEuler · LicenseRef-unstated
- OESA-2024-1489advisory covering several CVEsopenEuler · LicenseRef-unstated
- OESA-2024-2014advisory covering several CVEsopenEuler · LicenseRef-unstated
- OESA-2024-2015advisory covering several CVEsopenEuler · LicenseRef-unstated
- OESA-2025-2609advisory covering several CVEsopenEuler · LicenseRef-unstated
- openSUSE-SU-2024:0048-1advisory covering several CVEsopenSUSE · LicenseRef-unstated
- openSUSE-SU-2024:13687-1advisory covering several CVEsopenSUSE · LicenseRef-unstated
- openSUSE-SU-2024:13742-1advisory covering several CVEsopenSUSE · LicenseRef-unstated
- RHSA-2024:0965advisory covering several CVEsRed Hat · CC-BY-4.0
- RHSA-2024:0977advisory covering several CVEsRed Hat · CC-BY-4.0
- RHSA-2024:0981advisory covering several CVEsRed Hat · CC-BY-4.0
- RHSA-2024:0982advisory covering several CVEsRed Hat · CC-BY-4.0
- RHSA-2024:11003advisory covering several CVEsRed Hat · CC-BY-4.0
- RHSA-2024:1334advisory covering several CVEsRed Hat · CC-BY-4.0
- RHSA-2024:1335advisory covering several CVEsRed Hat · CC-BY-4.0
- RHSA-2024:1522advisory covering several CVEsRed Hat · CC-BY-4.0
- RHSA-2024:1543advisory covering several CVEsRed Hat · CC-BY-4.0
- RHSA-2024:1544advisory covering several CVEsRed Hat · CC-BY-4.0
- RHSA-2024:1545advisory covering several CVEsRed Hat · CC-BY-4.0
- RHSA-2024:1647advisory covering several CVEsRed Hat · CC-BY-4.0
- RHSA-2024:1648advisory covering several CVEsRed Hat · CC-BY-4.0
- RHSA-2024:1781advisory covering several CVEsRed Hat · CC-BY-4.0
- RHSA-2024:1782advisory covering several CVEsRed Hat · CC-BY-4.0
- RHSA-2024:1789advisory covering several CVEsRed Hat · CC-BY-4.0
Technical details
- CVSS v3 Vector
- CVSS:3.1/AV:N/AC:L/PR:N/UI:N/S:U/C:N/I:N/A:H
- Published
- 2024-02-14
- Last Modified
- 2026-06-17
- NVD status
- Analyzed
- GitHub Advisory
- GHSA-pv4h-p8jr-6cv2
Frequently asked questions
What is CVE-2023-50868?
Is CVE-2023-50868 actively exploited?
What is the CVSS score for CVE-2023-50868?
Running bind9? Hear about its next vulnerability
Surveillance reads the versions in your stack — a domain, a lockfile or a list — checks each CVE against the ranges its sources publish, and alerts you when one you run is exploited or enters CISA KEV. A version it cannot read stays « version not verified ».
No credit card required · No monthly cap on website lookups · 250 API requests/month
Go further
- Following what attackers exploit right now? The CISA KEV additions of the month, with their patch deadlines.
- Running this software? Vulnerability monitoring alerts you to new vulnerabilities in your products.
Related vulnerabilities
Same product first, then the same vendor advisory and the same publication week.
Sources for this record
- CISA ICS advisories (CSAF) · Public domain (US Government work)
- CVE Program · CVE Program Terms of Use
- ENISA EU Vulnerability Database · ENISA legal notice §1.2 (reproduction authorised, provided the source is acknowledged)
- FIRST EPSS · EPSS terms of use (free use, attribution requested)
- GitHub Advisory Database · CC-BY-4.0 · GHSA-pv4h-p8jr-6cv2
- NVD · Public domain (17 U.S.C. § 105) for NVD-authored data; third-party content under its own terms
- OSV.dev · Per record, as its publisher states it: each row carries the label in sourceLicense when one is served
- PoC-in-GitHub · CC0-1.0
- Red Hat Product Security (CSAF and VEX) · CC-BY-4.0
- Siemens ProductCERT (CSAF) · TLP:WHITE (commercial use and redistribution granted)
- CISA Vulnrichment · CC0-1.0